A Depersonalized Motherhood (aka, Parents are People Too).

The idealized “mother” is a self-contradictory creature: I am, at all times, the perfect and deeply flawed mother, depending on what ideology and latest-guru you consult. It is quite simply impossible to be the perfect mother from all perspectives, and trying to be such a thing will only lead to exhaustion, guilt, and a sense that this motherhood thing has passed you by, since you were so busy trying to live up to something impossible instead of living and loving.

This feeling of constantly being judged and found-wanting, is heightened of course with a special-needs child, because the scrutiny and the ideologies are that much more intense, and the notion that you will never have done enough for your child (or done too much even) weighs that much more heavily.

Over the years my body had started to show the strain; bent over more at the shoulders, avoiding others’ eyes, a sort of defensive exhaustedness that comes from getting used to a world that judges your child – and you – because they have a diagnosis (the mere act of seeking or achieving a diagnosis being a reason in itself for others’ superiority). I noticed this a while back and made a conscious effort to change my body to better reflect the strength and pride I have for my son and myself; a strength and pride that came with a better understanding of my son, and that I’m not to blame for his autism – to not even see autism as a “blameworthy” thing.

But going through motherhood under this much pressure – trying to live up to the ideals of other mothers and other mothers of special needs children – does more than leave you burnt out and bent over. It depersonalizes you, as a human being, in a number of ways. It depersonalizes you because you spend a lot of time externally observing and judging yourself, “have I done enough, did I do it right, will she think I did it right…” It also depersonalizes you because your own identity can melt away; your own interests and desires and passions are forgotten and moth-balled. The only thing you can not feel guilty about, is the passion for your child. The only social activities you can engage in, are those directed at your child’s well-being and development.

Your existence becomes referential; to the child. You are not “Emma” anymore, you are “mother of Sam.” This secondary, referential existence is one of the few ideals that carry through most mothering ideologies: The good mother is the one that holds every personal action up to question, “is this the best thing for my child?” The good mother always follows the child’s lead and never specifically encourages the child towards the mother’s own interests; that would be called “living through the child” otherwise (as opposed to, say, calling it engaging the child in what you are best able to teach them). The good mother puts her life on hold for at least the first three years of a child’s life, since the child is so dependent and easily influenced by the powerful figure of “mother” during those years.

But what happens when it’s not the first three years? Or five years? Or 18? What happens when the child is highly dependent all their life, and there is no point at which a mother is free to “rediscover” her friends and her own interests? She’s not allowed to be resentful about this of course – who is there to be resentful towards anyway, the child who had no choice in the matter either? No, you just keep mothering, under high scrutiny, and conflicting ideals. Listening to strangers and family alike tell you that you’re still doing too much for the child, or not enough, and knowing that you best never ask “what about me?”

The longer you survive in this high-stress and self-denying state, the more it becomes who you truly are. You don’t need others to judge you because you’ve internalized the conflicting judgments. You don’t need the disapproving looks and scowls because your biggest critic is yourself, and you’ll beat yourself up worse than anyone else would dare to. You become so wrapped up in your child that you realise one day that your non-existent free time would be wasted on you anyway, because your friends aren’t around anymore and the things you used to take pleasure in seem pointless and selfish now.

There are ways to avoid this of course; there’s nothing inevitable about such a depersonalized motherhood. You can find and stick to a particular parenting ideology and be prepared to defend it against the attackers (or to ignore the attacks, potentially by immersing yourself in the relevant community of agree-ers). You can take time through-out motherhood, and from early on in motherhood, to indulge yourself and maintain your friendships. You can remind yourself that “the perfect is the enemy of the good,” and just do your best while enjoying your child for who they are, while letting them see who you are too; an enriched two-way relationship between mother and child, rather than the sacrificial martyr one-way model.

And if you can’t step back from the attack that to care for yourself would be selfish, then remind yourself that the consequence of losing yourself completely to the role of “mother” – particularly in the special needs world where that role will take everything you have and then some – is a burnt-out person who may be no good to anyone anymore. Mental and physical break-downs will just make you a burden on the people you love anyway. There’s a lesson in the burn-out that I never truly knew until I first had one as a university student who pushed myself too hard, too long, too often: Once you burn-out, it is incredibly hard to re-find that specific past passion. It’s like a piece of you is broken, and that even when it seems healed, that it’s a weak point that can’t take too much pressure or it’ll break again very easily.

I think we need to remind ourselves – in society and as mothers – that “parents are people too.” Though we love our children and value them higher than our own lives – that there is nothing we wouldn’t sacrifice for them – their well-being requires us to be well too, mentally and physically. The more dependent they are on us, the even more important it is that we look after ourselves so we can be there for them.

I know, it’s easier said than done. We get told to take more time for ourselves, but who then follows through with the support to make it happen? Or we’re given that chance to step-back, and we don’t take it because for so long we’ve been the voice and aid of our child that it’s almost impossible to imagine someone else doing what needs to be done, or as well as it needs to be done. I have no easy answers. I’m stuck in this conundrum myself. But maybe it helps to say it out-loud sometimes, and know we’re not the only ones. Maybe that in itself is important, particularly in a world where speaking out about such things is so often itself attacked, as evidence that we are falling short as mothers.

Gallery | This entry was posted in Parenting an Autistic Child and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

15 Responses to A Depersonalized Motherhood (aka, Parents are People Too).

  1. Sharon says:

    I can’t tell you how timely this is. I will be sharing with some mums who very much need to hear this right now. As did I .

  2. þorgerður says:

    Been hanging around enjoying your posts and this one struck home…It is necessary to be a aware of this conundrum as you say and coming back from burn out is truly hard. Worrying about oneself often becomes a one more item on the to do list.

  3. dixieredmond says:

    This topic is important to talk about. And in a proactive way. Being sure you have a standing date with your spouse and with a couple of friends is important. I don’t have answers for how to make it happen, though. I have had the same babysitter for 12 years (thank God for her!) for a weekly dinner out with my husband. Hard to afford, but impossible not to afford, in retrospect. Friends have shifted and changed. That happens to all moms, I think. One of the things I wish I had done was stay connected with other parents of kids on the spectrum.

  4. dixieredmond says:

    But a follow-up. I disconnected with other autism moms around the time that people were injecting their children with miracle cures that had no science base.

    • You have my full understanding on that one dixieredmond; it is hard to keep quiet in those situations – there’s an innocent vulnerable child involved after all – but it always seems to damage the relationship when you speak up too, with little (if any) impact anyway on the parent’s decision. The lack of impact is hardly surprising though; when the importance of evidence and experts is thrown out the window, it’s a hard mind-set to counter. A sort of desperate stubborn-ness that I understand but have little sympathy for, considering its impact.

  5. Tsara says:

    Love this! I wrote a ‘Parenting Philosophy’ and stuck it up on my refrigerator reminding myself that I am always being an example for my boys, and to make sure I’m always one I can be proud of being. Since I ask my kids constantly to love, discover and be consistently kind to themselves, I must do the same!! It would be hypocritical for me to forget my own passions and interests only to tell them the importance of discovering theirs!! When I explain to them that comparing with others or allowing the judgments of others to muddy their belief in themselves, or get in the way of discovering what it is THEY think, I absolutely have to remember to do that myself! Funnily, it was my desire to be a great mom that made me come to these conclusions (and stick them on the fridge for those many moments I forget!) and insist on being kind to myself!

    The other day my youngest son said to me, “I can’t take it when I hear the guilt sound.” I figured I knew what he meant, but asked him to explain. “When people feel bad or sorry, I feel it too. And it kind of hurts me. So sometimes I just be mean because it makes me mad that they made me hurt. I’m going to stop doing that.” I can’t tell you how hard it was for me to keep my mouth shut and just let him have that learning all to himself. It’s one of the hardest jobs for me as a mom! Allowing them to discover themselves and trust them to find their own learning’s. Doing it for myself (by prioritizing my own needs) makes it easier to expect–and believe in it–from them!

    Thank-you for writing this and keeping the conversation going! It’s so, so, so important for us parents to remember that we aren’t alone and we are all doing a wonderful job by loving our families and doing our best! I kinda wrote a similar post (regarding that little voice in our heads that tries to hold us back with judgements and unkind reminders!) here: http://www.homestyle-mama.com/2012/05/guest-post-by-tsara-shelton.html

  6. “Please secure your own oxygen mask before helping others.”

    Love this post.

  7. Jennifer Butler Basile says:

    Thank you. For writing such a thought-provoking and positive (even though it handles such heart-breaking conundrums for mothers) post. For helping me understand the truly important aspects of motherhood (not being perfect, but living and loving). For helping me empathize with my best friend and godson’s mother.

  8. Pingback: Sharing the love « The Lady Garden

  9. 1 2 Next Change! says:

    Thank you for the post. Very well expressed!

Share your thoughts:

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s